Skip to main content
2004CASE #005
🛸 UFOs & UAPStill unexplained

The USS Nimitz “Tic Tac” Encounter

📅 14 November 2004  ·  📍 Pacific Ocean, off Southern California

In November 2004 a Navy cruiser off Southern California kept tracking objects that appeared at 80,000 feet and then dropped rapidly towards the sea. When two fighter jets went to look, the pilots found a white, oblong object about 40 feet long hovering over churning water. Its infrared video was published by The New York Times in 2017 and formally released by the Pentagon in 2020.

Date
14 November 2004
Location
Pacific Ocean, off Southern California
Status
Still unexplained
Category
UFOs & UAP
Key figures
David Fravor, Alex Dietrich, Chad Underwood

What happened

For several days in November 2004, radar operators on the cruiser USS Princeton, part of the USS Nimitz carrier group, tracked unusual objects appearing at very high altitude and dropping rapidly towards the sea.

On 14 November two F/A-18 Super Hornets were sent to intercept. Commander David Fravor and fellow pilot Alex Dietrich described a white, oblong object about 40 feet long hovering over a patch of churning water. Fravor said it “had no plumes, wings or rotors and outran our F-18s”. When he descended towards it, it rose to meet him, then accelerated away faster than anything he had seen.

“It accelerated like nothing I’ve ever seen.”
Commander David Fravor, speaking to The New York Times, December 2017

Later that day another crew, including Lieutenant Commander Chad Underwood, recorded the object with an infrared targeting camera. That clip, known as “FLIR”, was published in 2017 and officially released by the Pentagon in 2020. Fravor described the encounter to the US Congress in 2023.

Timeline

  1. November 2004
    USS Princeton tracks anomalous radar returns for several days.
  2. 14 November 2004
    Fravor and Dietrich encounter the object; a second crew films it on infrared.
  3. 16 December 2017
    The New York Times reports on the Pentagon’s UFO programme and publishes the video.
  4. 27 April 2020
    The Pentagon formally releases the footage.
  5. 26 July 2023
    Fravor testifies at a US House hearing on unidentified anomalous phenomena.

Key witnesses

  • Commander David Fravor

    Navy pilot sent to intercept. He saw a white, oval object about 40 feet long hovering above a disturbance in the sea, which rose as he descended and then disappeared. He testified to a House hearing in July 2023.

  • Alex Dietrich

    Fellow pilot sent with Fravor to investigate the object. She and Fravor later described the encounter together in an interview.

  • Lt Cdr Chad Underwood

    Recorded the FLIR infrared video, and coined the “Tic Tac” description.

The evidence

  1. 01Eyewitness accounts from four aircrew in two jets.
  2. 02Radar data from the USS Princeton, described by its operators (the raw data has not been made public).
  3. 03The FLIR infrared video recorded by Lt Cdr Chad Underwood and formally released by the Pentagon on 27 April 2020.

Debunked vs still unexplained

✓ Debunked

  • The video: mundane explanations put forward include instrument malfunction, parallax, and common aircraft or weather balloons. Skeptic Mick West has suggested the objects in the Navy videos “might well be commercial airplanes or balloons, distorted by the infrared glare”.

? Still unexplained

  • What the four aircrew saw with their own eyes for about five minutes: a white, oval object that rose to mirror Fravor’s jet, then disappeared.
  • The radar returns that, in Fravor’s testimony, showed objects “descending 80,000 feet in less than a second”.
  • The ocean disturbance the object was hovering above when the pilots arrived.

Sources and further reading

  1. Wikipedia: USS Nimitz UFO incident ↗
  2. The New York Times (republished by WRAL): 2 Airmen and an Object That ‘Accelerated Like Nothing I’ve Ever Seen’ ↗